Porsche 911 Turbo S vs McLaren 650 S Spider

Picture of McLaren 650 S Spider
Picture of Porsche 911 Turbo S (991)
Category McLaren 650 S SpiderPorsche 911 Turbo S
Max power (ps / bhp) 650 / 641560 / 552
Max torque (Nm / lb-ft) 678 / 500750 / 553
Curb weight (kg / lb) 1477 / 32561592 / 3510
Power / tonne (ps / bhp) 440 / 434352 / 347

Acceleration (mph)

Speed & distance McLaren 650 S SpiderPorsche 911 Turbo S
0 - 30 mph 1.3 s0.9 s
0 - 40 mph 1.8 s1.4 s
0 - 50 mph 2.3 s1.9 s
0 - 60 mph 2.8 s2.5 s
0 - 70 mph 3.5 s3.3 s
0 - 80 mph 4.2 s4.1 s
0 - 90 mph 5.0 s5.1 s
0 - 100 mph 5.8 s6.2 s
0 - 110 mph 7.1 s7.4 s
0 - 120 mph 8.3 s8.9 s
0 - 130 mph 9.9 s10.6 s
0 - 150 mph 13.2 s14.9 s
Est. 1/8 mile 7.3 s @ 111.8 mph7.2 s @ 109.4 mph
1/4 mile 10.5 s @ 136.1 mph10.6 s @ 130.5 mph
Est. 1/2 mile 17.3 s @ 167.8 mph17.7 s @ 160.9 mph

Acceleration (kph)

Speed & distance McLaren 650 S SpiderPorsche 911 Turbo S
0 - 40 kph 1.2 s0.9 s
0 - 50 kph 1.5 s1.1 s
0 - 60 kph 1.9 s1.4 s
0 - 80 kph 2.4 s2.1 s
0 - 100 kph 3.0 s2.8 s
0 - 120 kph 4.0 s3.8 s
0 - 130 kph 4.3 s4.3 s
0 - 140 kph 5.0 s5.0 s
0 - 180 kph 7.0 s7.8 s
0 - 200 kph 8.6 s9.6 s
0 - 250 kph 13.8 s15.7 s
0 - 300 kph 23.5 s29.7 s
1000 m 19.7 s @ 271.0 kph19.9 s @ 270.0 kph
Est. 100 - 140 kph 2.0 s2.3 s
Est. 100 - 200 kph 5.7 s6.8 s
Est. 200 - 300 kph 16.0 s20.1 s

Braking distance

Speed McLaren 650 S SpiderPorsche 911 Turbo S
100 kph - 0 31 m (103 ft)32 m (104 ft)
200 kph - 0 121 m (397 ft)128 m (419 ft)
60 mph - 0 32 m (105 ft)30 m (98 ft)
70 mph - 0 47 m (155 ft)44 m (144 ft)

General performance

Category McLaren 650 S SpiderPorsche 911 Turbo S
Top speed 329 kph (204 mph)318 kph (198 mph)
Est. 0 - 100 mph - 0 10.2 s @ 732 ft10.3 s @ 758 ft
Est. max acceleration 0.98 g (10 m/s²)1.10 g (11 m/s²)
18m slalom 71.8 kph (44.6 mph)71.8 kph (44.6 mph)
Fuel economy 10.7 l/100 km (22 mpg US / 26 UK)14.1 l/100 km (17 mpg US / 20 UK)
Lateral acceleration 1.07 g (10 m/s²)1.09 g (11 m/s²)

Summary

Category McLaren 650 S SpiderPorsche 911 Turbo S
Track Performance 10801062
Straight line speed 36623690
Total 47424752

Verdict

There is no clear winner in this comparison.

This comparison has been viewed 5k times.

User avatar
User avatar

uptownfunker  8y ago

McLaren still says 204-205 mph for all of its entry-level cars. Is there a governor limiting the 650S to 204? I read somewhere that the 592hp 12C could do 205.


User avatar

uptownfunker  8y ago

Actually in straight line speed AND in total scoring the 911 TS is faster. Just from looking at the scores.


User avatar

fakekillerfour  8y ago

650S Spider wins 6-3 on tracks
650S Spider wins 9-5 on performance figures

so 650S Spider is noticeably faster than 991 Turbo S!.


User avatar

audis14  8y ago

Actual Scores

Track performance:

991 Turbo S (650S Spider)

Nordschleife by 'sport auto' - 7:34 (7:35)
Hockenheim Short - 1:08.7 (1:08.7)
Willow Springs - 1:27.17 (1:25.88)
Autocar Dry Handling Track - 1:09.6 (1:08.3)
Autocar Wet Handling Track - 1:18.5 (1:16.9)
Ring Knutstrop - 1:08.1 (1:07.6)
Goodwood Hill climb - 0:53.9 (0:55.73)

~Score: 200 : 400

Straight line speed:

991 Turbo S (650S Spider)

0-100 kph - 2.8 s (3.0 s)
0-200 kph - 9.6 s (8.6 s)
0-300 kph - 29.7 s (26.0 s)

~Score: 100 : 200

Total Score:

650S Spider: 600
991 Turbo S: 300

The verdict:

McLaren 650S Spider is noticeably faster.


User avatar

Specialestradale  9y ago

1/4 mile

991 TTS coupe - 10.6 seconds @ 128 mph
650S Spider - 11.0 seconds @ 135 mph

0-300 km/h

650S Spider - 26.0 seconds
991 TTS coupe - 29.7 seconds

top speed

650S Spider - 204 mph
991 TTS coupe - 197 mph


User avatar

aaaa  9y ago

@saxy: I actually agree, it's clear that the 650s is faster around the track given the laptimes, and taking into account the previous generations.

@derb: how is it a stupid comment? you say that we can't consider autocar because of bias, yet hockenheim where they clearly favour porsches, the 650s still managed to tie the 911, as for goodwood, one only has to look at the laptimes to see that it's not a true test of a cars performance. see if we start eliminating laptimes that leaves ring knutstrop, (a german track) and the 650s comes out on top. so please enlighten me in what way is the 911 faster?


User avatar

saxy  9y ago

The old 12c spyder mulled the Turbo S. no surprise here really.


User avatar

Hans  9y ago

We need more times.
650s should be faster because it's proper super car and Turbo S sporty GT.


User avatar

Derb  9y ago

@aaaa

really stupid comment

thera are only 3 useful track numbers
you can't take autocar seriously
when britihsh cars are tested

and in only one of the 3 tracks the 650 is faster


User avatar

aaaa  9y ago

looks like the 650s will pretty much dust the turbo s at both kinds of tracks (with goodwood as the only exception)


User avatar

Hans  9y ago

Looks like 650S is faster on fast track and Turbo on technical tracks without many straights straights.


User avatar

196ss  9y ago

Can't understand how RWD 650S can be faster then AWD Turbo on the wet handling track.