Porsche 911 Carrera S vs BMW M3

Category	BMW M3 (E92)	911 Carrera S
Engine layout	4.0 l V8	3.8 l B6
Max power (ps / bhp)	420 / 414	355 / 350
Max torque (Nm / lb-ft)	400 / 295	400 / 295
Curb weight (kg / lb)	1625 / 3583	1475 / 3252
Power / tonne (ps / bhp)	259 / 255	241 / 237
Average price	€77,000	€90,000

Lap Times

Track	BMW M3 (E92)	911 Carrera S
Vairano Handling Course	1:20.10	1:20.74
Balocco	2:55.22	2:55.51
Tsukuba	1:05.33	1:05.48
Motortrend Figure-8	0:24.40	0:24.80
Hockenheim Short	1:14.00	1:16.60
Willow Springs	1:36.92	1:36.51
Winton (National Circuit)	1:37.78	1:38.25
Nürburgring Nordschleife	8:05.00	7:56.00
Gotland Ring (Northern Loop)	1:36.30	1:36.60
Autocar Wet Handling Track	1:16.90	1:09.20
SportAuto wet handling test	1:32.40	1:28.40
Laguna Seca (post 1988)	1:42.96	1:50.00
Autozeitung test track	1:40.10	1:39.80
Fuji Speedway (post 2005)	2:02.07	2:01.18

Acceleration (mph)

Speed & distance	BMW M3 (E92)	911 Carrera S
0 - 30 mph	1.7 s	1.5 s
0 - 40 mph	2.5 s	2.0 s
0 - 50 mph	3.3 s	3.1 s
0 - 60 mph	4.2 s	3.9 s
0 - 70 mph	5.6 s	5.1 s
0 - 80 mph	7.1 s	6.4 s
0 - 90 mph	8.6 s	8.2 s
0 - 100 mph	9.8 s	9.6 s
0 - 110 mph	12.7 s	12.2 s
0 - 120 mph	15.1 s	14.4 s
0 - 140 mph	22.5 s	21.1 s
0 - 150 mph	23.9 s	26.4 s
Est. 1/8 mile	9.0 s @ 95.1 mph	9.0 s @ 95.1 mph
1/4 mile	12.4 s @ 114.3 mph	12.3 s

Acceleration (kph)

Speed & distance	BMW M3 (E92)	911 Carrera S
0 - 60 kph	2.6 s	2.1 s
0 - 80 kph	3.2 s	3.5 s
0 - 100 kph	4.3 s	4.6 s
0 - 120 kph	6.1 s	6.4 s
0 - 130 kph	6.9 s	7.3 s
0 - 140 kph	7.8 s	8.2 s
0 - 160 kph	9.9 s	10.5 s
0 - 180 kph	12.4 s	13.0 s
0 - 200 kph	15.2 s	16.0 s
1000 m	23.5 s @ 230.0 kph	23.4 s @ 230.1 kph

Rolling acceleration

Speed	BMW M3 (E92)	911 Carrera S
60 - 100 kph (4)	4.3 s	5.2 s
60 - 100 kph (5)	5.5 s	6.5 s
80 - 120 kph (4)	4.4 s	5.2 s
80 - 120 kph (5)	5.4 s	6.3 s
80 - 120 kph (6)	6.1 s	8.9 s
Est. 100 - 140 kph	3.7 s	3.9 s
Est. 100 - 200 kph	10.9 s	11.7 s
5 - 60 mph	4.9 s	5.0 s

Braking distance

Speed	BMW M3 (E92)	911 Carrera S
100 kph - 0	34 m (111 ft)	35 m (115 ft)
190 kph - 0	124 m (408 ft)	127 m (417 ft)
30 mph - 0	8 m (27 ft)	8 m (28 ft)
60 mph - 0	33 m (109 ft)	32 m (104 ft)
70 mph - 0	45 m (147 ft)	44 m (144 ft)

General performance

Category	BMW M3 (E92)	911 Carrera S
Top speed	280 kph (174 mph)	293 kph (182 mph)
Est. max acceleration	0.65 g (6 m/s²)	0.67 g (7 m/s²)
18m slalom	70.1 kph (43.6 mph)	67.9 kph (42.2 mph)
Fuel economy	9.2 l/100 km (26 mpg US / 31 UK)	8.9 l/100 km (26 mpg US / 32 UK)
Lateral acceleration	0.97 g (10 m/s²)	0.98 g (10 m/s²)

Summary

Category	BMW M3 (E92)	911 Carrera S
Track Performance	99	100
Straight line speed	99	100
Overall	99	100

Verdict

There is no clear winner in this comparison.

This comparison has been viewed 7.3k times.

The winner! 9y ago

Porsche wins, end of.

2

what 14y ago

I would argue that based on the data the M3 is the quicker car

1

jeremyclarkson1 8m ago

yeah, the two wet handling circuits the Porsche is much faster on, which is why it has more track points, but I think without them the M3 may be slightly quicker

1