11 Nothing wrong with a BMW minivan

Cover for Nothing wrong with a BMW minivan

As BMW's Active Tourer minivan concept continues to "actively tour" auto shows around the world, it becomes certain that BMW will indeed venture into minivan segment.

Just like 10 years ago, when BMW first entered SUV market with first generation BMW X5, the purist section of BMW fan base is not going to be happy.

For them it seems like another chapter in the "How BMW diluted themselves to hatchback and minivan company" story. Another nail in the coffin in which soon BMW's last bits of credibility and image will be buried forever. For them it's an unwelcome and unloved newborn in the BMW family.

I realize that there is no way I could claim myself amongst the BMW purists, because I really have nothing against a BMW minivan. BMW have already spread their presence far beyond the sports sedan. Not only in the SUV and crossover segments but also in the very lucrative "Golf class" and, soon, in the various electric and hybrid markets.

BMW has never been a one trick pony sports sedan company. BMW have always focused on engine development, providing powertrain for various car manufacturers, as well as making vehicles themselves. These vehicles were not limited to four door sedans or coupes. BMW were making motorcycles before they ever got into cars. And some of the cars that carried a BMW badge were far from being "sports" or "sedan" - think Isetta "bubble car".

For me, the essence of BMW is not as much about certain vehicle body type or engine configuration as it is about making the best powertrain and providing best driving dynamics in any given class of vehicles.

Of course, I would prefer the Active Tourer to be world's first minivan with longitudinally mounted, naturally aspirated inline six and rear wheel drive. At the same time I realize that is a silly idea and BMW's proposed 3 cylinder hybrid solution is far superior in every measurable quality.

There are, of course, unmeasurable qualities that a classic BMW layout has, and future electric and hybrid powertrains won't have. But so does a typewriter, a horse and a carriage or a candle lamp. This doesn't mean you would prefer to commute in a horse carriage and do your e-mails without the "e", in candle light, typing on a 1930s typewriter.

Times change and so must our stagnated stereotypes of what certain brands should or should not represent. Let the sales figures decide whether or not a BMW minivan was a good idea.

12y ago by FastestLaps
User avatar
User avatar

Shaggy  12y ago

I would. :D


User avatar

Fangio Man  12y ago

I do not have a problem with a BMW minivan.

I just would not buy it. :p


User avatar

72  12y ago

@fasdf Any other ugly Bimmer, like an E30 M3.... really ugly. Right. I'd like to see BMW expand its lineup with a true sport car capable of a 7:15 Nordschleife lap time. Where's the M1 Hommage?


User avatar

NIN  12y ago

I don't have a problem with any car company expanding their lineup by going into areas that they've never been.

Porsche wanted to build a SUV, I had no problem with it.
Porsche wanted to build a sedan, I had no problem with it.
As long as they continue to offer the cars that they are known for, who cares? In fact, the sales of the SUVs and sedans pours more money into developing the sports cars.

If Porsche said "we will cease 911 production and only build SUVs and sedans...", THEN I'd be furious.

So BMW wants a minivan...big deal. It doesn't hurt their 3(4),5(6),and 7 series sedans and coupes. It doesn't hurt the M division.

I think the problem is that fanboys who love BMW are afraid that BMW's image will change to something embarrassing. I'm not blindly loyal to anything. If I like it, I like it. If I don't, I don't.


User avatar

72  12y ago

Can't stand these arguments that defend whatever happens to come along. A BMW minivan... that's good. What's next, a BMW lawnmower, a BMW washer & dryer. Like a Porsche truckling, oooh, it's a Porsche, I got to have one. Great for sales, and goes on to dilute the lineage of the company into the morass of mediocrity for the lemming masses... but we're makin' lots of money!!!


User avatar

72  12y ago

r


User avatar

FastestLaps  12y ago

Mercedes R-Class is pretty much a minivan already.


User avatar

Mental  12y ago

Minivans... I've heard Audi is going to introduce its Van too.. And if BMW and Audi bring their minivans into the production, then no surprise if Mercedes would join them... and then Jaguar.. Maserari... Porsche...


User avatar

Anonimity is Great  12y ago

However, I think they should stop here. It would be a real let down for me if, for example, BMW starts producing trucks to figt ford F150s..


User avatar

Anonimity is Great  12y ago

As long as the car it produces is better than the rest of the pact, no images will be diluted.


User avatar

Shaggy  12y ago

I don't have a problem with it, BMW is known for making cool cars and SUVs, maybe, the Active Tourer minivan might attract more people to minivans, I never had a problem with minivans, they're comfortable, fuel efficient and can carry a lot of people and stuff, and they're great for long trips. I think peoples' insecurities about being seen driving minivans are ill conceived, too many people, including young adults around my age are ashamed to drive them, the prospect of driving a minivan makes them cry themselves to sleep at night, believe me, minivans can be cool. I'm one of the only young people I know who wouldn't mind driving a minivan, I even had one for a little while. There are cool minivans out there, ex: Dodge Grand Caravan, Chrysler Town & Country, they have a 283 horsepower 3.6 liter V6 and a top speed of 138 MPH. This one from BMW looks pretty sweet, I hope they produce it, but instead of making it a hybrid, give it the 3.0 liter inline 6 from the BMW 328i.