There aren't enough test results to state rather or not the Audi TT-S gives the base Porsche Cayman a run for the money. Regardless of the numbers the Cayman is still leaps and bounds the better driver's car.
It's the same thing with Audi TT-RS vs. Porsche Cayman S. No comparison Cayman S > Audi TT-RS. It's not that the Audi is total crap just that the Cayman is really good were it most matters.
But then again I suppose it depends on what camp you’re in. I myself love the act of driving, like feeling > at one
with my car and so on. Others may be more about > the numbers
, interior quality and so on.
This is why I’d take an E90/92 M3, Cayman S or Lotus Evora any day over a Nissan GT-R despite how much quicker it goes from 0-60mph, around the > RING
and so on. Now if I raced my daily driver for a living or something crazy like that I’d obviously go for the GT-R.