Picture of Ferrari 458 Italia

Ferrari 458 Italia

V8
570 ps (562 bhp)
540 Nm (398 lb-ft)
1485 kg (3274 lbs)
384 ps / tonne
Picture of McLaren MP4-12C

McLaren MP4-12C

V8 twin turbo
600 ps (591 bhp)
600 Nm (443 lb-ft)
1434 kg (3161 lbs)
418 ps / tonne

Lap Times 15

  458 ItaliaMP4-12C
Laguna Seca (post 1988) 1:36.221:34.50
Anglesey National 0:59.200:59.30
Rockingham International Super Sportscar 1:28.301:29.24
Hockenheim Short 1:09.701:08.70
Spring Mountain (Radical loop section) 1:17.991:19.23
Motortrend Figure-8 0:23.600:23.20
Nürburgring Nordschleife 7:38.007:28.00
Vairano Handling Course 1:15.141:14.81
Autocar Dry Handling Track 1:08.901:08.60
Top Gear Track 1:19.101:16.20
SportAuto wet handling test 1:33.601:38.70
Autocar Wet Handling Track 1:12.701:19.10
Bedford Autodrome West Circuit (post 06/2008) 1:19.301:19.60
Mireval 1:31.601:30.58
Balocco 2:43.902:43.46

Performance

  458 ItaliaMP4-12C
Top speed 338 kph (210 mph)333 kph (207 mph)
0 - 40 kph 1.3 s1.2 s
0 - 50 kph 1.5 s1.3 s
0 - 60 kph 1.9 s1.8 s
0 - 80 kph 2.6 s2.3 s
0 - 100 kph 3.1 s3.0 s
0 - 180 kph 8.2 s7.3 s
0 - 200 kph 9.2 s8.7 s
0 - 250 kph 16.0 s14.8 s
0 - 300 kph 32.4 s31.0 s
0 - 40 mph 1.7 s1.8 s
0 - 60 mph 3.0 s2.9 s
0 - 100 mph 6.2 s5.9 s
0 - 150 mph 15.0 s13.9 s
Est. 1/8 mile 7.2 s @ 108.1 mph7.0 s @ 111.2 mph
1/4 mile 10.8 s @ 134.2 mph10.7 s @ 135.5 mph
Est. 1/2 mile 17.1 s @ 155.3 mph16.9 s @ 157.2 mph
Est. 1 mile 28.0 s @ 176.5 mph27.6 s @ 178.3 mph
1000 m 19.6 s @ 271.0 kph19.4 s @ 272.0 kph
60 mph - 0 30 m (99 ft)32 m (106 ft)
70 mph - 0 45 m (146 ft)44 m (145 ft)
Lateral acceleration 1.02 g (10 m/s²)1.06 g (10 m/s²)

Summary

  458 ItaliaMP4-12C
Track Performance 14621454
Straight line speed 19332161
Total 33953615

Verdict

MP4-12C is the fastest by a small margin.

This comparison has been viewed 10873 times.

Acceleration graph

Acceleration chart
User avatar

User avatar

12345678  2y  

The drivers differs A LOT..


User avatar

saxy  3y  

there are a ton of 12C drag races. yeah, much of the figures were not revised.

And yeah, all 12Cs should be accepted as the 625ps version because all old version got free upgrades


User avatar

The truth  3y  

.I find it funny that the 1/4mile 1/2 mile, 1000m, 1mile times are so similar, yet every drag race between these 2 cars it's been a complete massacre. .

  • Mp4-12c data not updated at 625Hp version
  • 458 data are in lightest config possible (Press cars ...)
  • Drag race you refer ... MP4-12C not stock with rear wider tires and R888

User avatar

saxy  3y  

I find it funny that the 1/4mile 1/2 mile, 1000m, 1mile times are so similar, yet every drag race between these 2 cars it's been a complete massacre.


User avatar

saxy  3y  

ferrari 458 is much faster on wet tracks.

yet Clarkson says the traction system on the 12C really shines in the wet...

honestly it's simple science. turbo engines have too much torque and you either spin the wheels, wasting all the power, or you go gingerly. This is what's going to be interesting next year in formula 1 when they have 4x the torque but same power...


User avatar

porsche guy  3y  

ferrari 458 is much faster on wet tracks.


User avatar

Karthick01  4y  

This Result was Very Unexpected,I Expected McLaren To Win.


User avatar

....  4y  

McLaren is faster, but I more love Ferrari


User avatar

remengo  5y  

Hehehe I get ya Grand****ingpieceof shit, I get ya in you ****ing british balls....you have a ****ing small brain if you think that te veyron is a british car and it looks that mathematics are not in your ****ing knowledge, stick to macca's third production car, THREE cars in fifteen years what a great history hahahahaha and a ****ing radical go-cart which can be road legal only in your lovely country....you will have to eat a lot of shit.....


User avatar

G  5y  

@Remengo

So you're saying the scoring system is somehow set up in favour of British cars? ****ing idiot.

Look CLOSELY at the lap times. The MP4 wins most of the comparisons. Obviously another bottle-nosed Italian who can't take defeat.


User avatar

remengo  5y  

HAHAHAHA the macca is noticeably faster HAHAHAHA!
Fantastic criteria set for this comparison, track performance 70 points and straight line speed ten times more!! Then no need further calculations to say that the veyron is the winner and the radicals are crap…..
Thanks god the 458 is a better car, is winning in all racing categories (le mans too) where the macca’s are not able to finish the race……and do not bollock with “this is not comparison between racing cars” please…. (see Sunday’s nurburgring .autosport.com/news/report.php/id/102791)
Anyway, my compliments to this example of typical british fairness and impartiality.


User avatar

F355  5y  

F458 vs MP4-12C, updated.

MP4-12C wins 8-5 on dry track (by 0.5%/0.3% average/median)
458 wins 5-1 in direct comparisons on dry track (by 0.5%/0.3%)
458 wins 2-0 on wet track (by 7.1%/7.1%)

Winner per track (relevant comparisons, no manufacturer times)...
Dry Track:
MP4-12C by 3.8% Top Gear (1:19.1 vs 1:16.2)
MP4-12C by 2.2% Nordschleife (7:38 by HvS vs 7:28)
MP4-12C by 0.4% Vairano (1:15.14 vs 1:14.81)
MP4-12C by 0.4% Autocar Dry (1:08.9 vs 1:08.6)
MP4-12C by 1.1% Mireval (1:31.60 vs 1:30.58)
MP4-12C by 1.8% Laguna Seca (1:36.22 vs 1:34.50)
MP4-12C by 0.3% Balocco (2:43.90 vs 2:43.46)
MP4-12C by 0.3% DIRECT COMPARISON Hockenheim Short (1:09.7 vs 1:09.5)
458 by 0.4% DIRECT COMPARISON Bedford (1:19.3 vs 1:19.6)
458 by 0.2% DIRECT COMPARISON Anglesey (59.2 vs 59.3)
458 by 1.1% DIRECT COMPARISON Rockingham ISS (1:28.30 vs 1:29.24)
458 by 0.1% DIRECT COMPARISON FifthGear
458 by 1.6% DIRECT COMPARISON Spring Mountain Radical (1:17.99 vs 1:19.23)
Wet Track:
458 by 8.8% Autocar Wet (1:12.7 vs 1:19.1)
458 by 5.4% Sport Auto Wet (1:33.6 vs 1:38.7)


User avatar

G  5y  

Unsurprisingly, Luque is Italian.


User avatar

Piorun  5y  

It's simple!
Mclaren is a bit faster than the 458 Italia on the dry. The 458 Italia is much faster than the McLaren in the wet!

That difrences are based usually mostly on specific tires.
Also MP4 track systems may slow it down on bad conditions.


User avatar

M Power  5y  

It's simple!
Mclaren is a bit faster than the 458 Italia on the dry.

The 458 Italia is much faster than the McLaren in the wet!


User avatar

tommy boy and co  5y  

it won fragile car of the year, didnt it ?


User avatar

NIN  5y  

To be fair, the MP4-12C couldn't win some of those...:)

  • 2011 International Engine of the Year above 4.0
    -- Best of the Best for 2010 – Robb Report
    -- Car of the Year 2010 and Supercar of the Year – Car Middle East
    -- Supercar of the Year 2010 – Top Gear China
    -- Most Admired Sports Car 2010 – Xcar website
    -- No. 1 of top 10 cars of 2010 -- New York Times
    -- 2010 Best Exotic Car – Middle East Motor Awards

User avatar

Luque  5y  

Yeah just one. So ****ing what? The VW Passat won MT(?) or R&T car of the year. Just subjective mumbo-jumbo

I'm sorry if you can not understand.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kcCNzbtManQ
Why does she have so ******ic reaction ?
Of course another subjective Jumbo Mumbo ...


User avatar

Luque  5y  

Most of the Ferrari 458 Italia in Anglesey National is 00:59:20, or 0.1 faster than the McLaren MP4-12C. . McLaren had inferior tyres in that test.

You again misinform.
Autoexpress doesn’t refer to tires in the PCOTY 2011. You don’t have any source but of course you try to justify another MP4-12c defeat in same day comparison versus the 458
After Rockingham and Bedford defeats by 458 (over 1 seconds), Mc Laren have sent press car with P-Zero corsa and, see Sport Auto test, with track optimized wheel adjustments.
The new Pirelli P-Zero is bit faster than a PS2 as showed by few magazine comparison
http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/2010-Sport-Auto-Ultra-High-Performance-Tyre-Test.htm
http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/2010-Auto-Bild-Ultra-High-Performance-Tyre-Test.htm
I wonder why you don’t refer to inferior tires (Michelin PS2) of the 458 when comparing Autocar, Quattroruote, Sport Auto test laptime to those of the MP4-12c done with Pzero Corsa.


User avatar

w0o0dy  5y  

@F355: with the main editor racing the 997 GT3 RS it makes sense that he will be quite a bit faster in the Porsche than in any other car. The man has done thousands of laps on racetracks with the 911 in every possible variation..

Timeline

User avatar
sroser 9h 

added laptime for Porsche 911 GT3 RS (991)

User avatar
sroser 10h 

added laptime for McLaren 675LT

User avatar
fakekillerfour 10h 

added laptime for Porsche 911 Carrera S (991 facelift) and data for Porsche 911 Carrera S (991 facelift)

Active users

BR2+, FastestLaps, Chanante, saxy, tyler, sroser, fakekillerfour, Georg, NIN, gtrs, 777Balt, PAPPACLART, lafars, CMRDNOOB, britishbikes

Latest topics

Mercedes-AMG GT R 7:10.92 min Nordschleife HOT LAP sport auto World's Exclusive First Test 33
12 hours ago by sroser

Porsche 918 beats McLaren P1 and "the Ferrari" in Grand Tour opening 215
1 day ago by BR2+

VW improve front wheel drive Nürburgring record with "7:47" for the Golf Clubsport S 3
1 day ago by FastestLaps

Aston Martin DB11 beats Dodge Challenger Hellcat in a Grand Tour duel - here are the lap times 9
4 days ago by saxy

What I saw on YouTube today 56
5 days ago by tharne

LMP1 cars are welcome 8
6 days ago by Driveitlikeyoustoleit